Which would you prefer?

Let's say you are looking for Roswell Transcripts for example... (but would also be for images/affiliates/links/extras as well)

Would you rather it be at the top of the forum, as a button (the way it is now) that you can click to get to the entire list of Transcripts?

or

Would you rather the entire list of Transcripts be listed as a topic post in this forum and sticky'd at the top of the posts?

What would be easier for you to be able to find what you are looking for? Need some random opinions and general thoughts on this?

Well, it was brought to my attention that "newbies" might not ever see the buttons or might not be able to find "Roswell" transcripts if they were looking for them. It never crossed my mind that people wouldn't see the buttons... but that's because *I* know they are there... so I was wondering from a "newbie" POV if they notice them or not, I guess?

Well, I guess that answers that question.

and on top it, now we have the navigational menu at the top, anyone can hit What's Hot and then there is the Transcripts/Images/etc.